samizdis · 34 points · 9 comments · 3 日前 · Open original
Comments
5 preview comments · loading full thread
Log in to use comments
Log in to h4cker, then connect Hacker News to publish comments.
PApazimzadeh1 時間前
> All three of the languages in the Persian inscriptions were a complete mystery: Old Persian, Elamite, and Akkadian
> One of the languages (Old Persian) turned out to be related to modern Persian, in which Rawlinson was fluent, and in 1846 he published an edition and translation of the inscription.
Fascinating. I wonder if there were any other Persian speakers at the time who could have helped with this, or was this mainly about Rawlinson hoarding the glory?
> The results were published in scholarly journals, sometimes leading to collaboration and discoveries, and sometimes laying bare fierce rivalries and competing theories. Rawlinson, for example, was initially convinced that cuneiform represented letters rather than syllables, and that it originated in Egypt. When he changed his mind and started reading the signs as syllables, he claimed not to remember how he had come to these conclusions, but seems to have plagiarised Hincks, as he also copied some of his mistakes.
There we go.
HEhermitcrab41 分前
If you are at all interested in this, I would strongly recommend a visit to the Assyrian section of the British Museum in London. The carved reliefs are incredible and look like they were done yesterday.
RMrmunn2 時間前
This has nothing to do with the library of Ashurbanipal itself, but is still worth mentioning. Ashurbanipal's library gets referenced in the VERY clever parody song "I Am the Very Model of a Biblical Philologist", which you can watch on the author's channel here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3x2SvqhfevE (video is under 4 minutes long).
Depending on your knowledge of ancient history and archaeology, you may find the song either mildly funny, or side-splittingly hilarious. (And no particular religious position is advanced in the song, it's pure silliness. Putting that out there in case anyone was worried by the title). Personally, I landed on the "hilarious" side of things, which is why I wanted to share this video with you all.
I hope this brightens up your day a little.
TItimvdalen1 時間前
Only tangentially related, but I can really recommend There are Rivers In The Sky by Elif Shafak, which starts in this library
REretrac2 時間前
I find it fascinating how self-aware the Mespotamians were of their own literary culture and history. Later rulers would do early forms of archaeology and dig up the ruins of earlier kings. The Library of Ashurbanipal has sign lists (proto-dictionaries) which go way, way back, to the early Sumerian period, and it seems the Assyrian elite could still read inscriptions that were over two thousand years old, when Nineveh fell in 612 BC.
Comments
5 preview comments · loading full threadLog in to h4cker, then connect Hacker News to publish comments.
> All three of the languages in the Persian inscriptions were a complete mystery: Old Persian, Elamite, and Akkadian > One of the languages (Old Persian) turned out to be related to modern Persian, in which Rawlinson was fluent, and in 1846 he published an edition and translation of the inscription. Fascinating. I wonder if there were any other Persian speakers at the time who could have helped with this, or was this mainly about Rawlinson hoarding the glory? > The results were published in scholarly journals, sometimes leading to collaboration and discoveries, and sometimes laying bare fierce rivalries and competing theories. Rawlinson, for example, was initially convinced that cuneiform represented letters rather than syllables, and that it originated in Egypt. When he changed his mind and started reading the signs as syllables, he claimed not to remember how he had come to these conclusions, but seems to have plagiarised Hincks, as he also copied some of his mistakes. There we go.
If you are at all interested in this, I would strongly recommend a visit to the Assyrian section of the British Museum in London. The carved reliefs are incredible and look like they were done yesterday.
This has nothing to do with the library of Ashurbanipal itself, but is still worth mentioning. Ashurbanipal's library gets referenced in the VERY clever parody song "I Am the Very Model of a Biblical Philologist", which you can watch on the author's channel here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3x2SvqhfevE (video is under 4 minutes long). Depending on your knowledge of ancient history and archaeology, you may find the song either mildly funny, or side-splittingly hilarious. (And no particular religious position is advanced in the song, it's pure silliness. Putting that out there in case anyone was worried by the title). Personally, I landed on the "hilarious" side of things, which is why I wanted to share this video with you all. I hope this brightens up your day a little.
Only tangentially related, but I can really recommend There are Rivers In The Sky by Elif Shafak, which starts in this library
I find it fascinating how self-aware the Mespotamians were of their own literary culture and history. Later rulers would do early forms of archaeology and dig up the ruins of earlier kings. The Library of Ashurbanipal has sign lists (proto-dictionaries) which go way, way back, to the early Sumerian period, and it seems the Assyrian elite could still read inscriptions that were over two thousand years old, when Nineveh fell in 612 BC.